First published: Sun 14 Feb 2021.
Els Slots
The Egyptian Museum
Comments
6 comments
Nan
4 years, 5 months ago (Feb 14, 2021)
I think the comparison with the Museumsinsel is off. The Museumsinsel was built roughly 90 years before the Egyptian Museum. I also don't see OUV if the collection is removed.
The connection to the Museumsinsel is rather via it's most prominent artefact: the bust of Nofretete. But then you would also have to name the British Museum ;)
Reply
Kyle Magnuson
4 years, 5 months ago (Feb 14, 2021)
It seems mostly irrelevant if some of the highlights are moved to other modern facilities. From what I read, tens of thousands of artifacts are in storage and rotated into the exhibits. Furthermore, Egypt is not lacking in priceless treasures. In our Connection "Museum History", WHS containing locations that have been important in international museum history, none are outside Europe. That alone makes me supportive at least in theory, but I lack first hand knowledge of the museum itself.
Jay T
4 years, 5 months ago (Feb 14, 2021)
I would hazard that one point of OUV is that it was an early attempt to keep and showcase a culture’s archaeological treasures and artifacts in country, rather than taken to other countries for display. I agree that the heart of the OUV would be in the treasures on display, but the building itself provided an early example of displaying antiquities within the cultural region they were found, instilling a sense of ownership by the people. I am really curious to see what happens with this TWHS when the new museum opens, though.
Nan
4 years, 5 months ago (Feb 14, 2021)
Hmn. I think it's hard to separate the content from the location. The Museumsinsel is great because you can walk through the Gates of Babylon. Or visit Pergammon. Will be interesting to see what goes where @kyle.
@jay good phrasing for ouv. still, this is a colonial museum, so clearly traces back to europe.
Jay T
4 years, 5 months ago (Feb 15, 2021)
It's true the museum is a colonial museum -- in fact modern Egyptology itself is deeply entwined with colonialism. The downside of Egyptology in the 18th and 19th centuries was that many treasures were taken away to Europe and a black market for goods from tombs was established. However, colonialism also brought the establishment of the Department of Antiquities in the 19th century, which led to the construction of the Egyptian Museum in the early 20th century to display the department's treasures, and eventually led to Egyptians gaining autonomy over their own heritage.
As a side note, I do wonder what the impetus for UNESCO World Heritage would have been if it were not for Egyptology...
khuft
4 years, 4 months ago (Feb 18, 2021)
Actually, why Egyptology was certainly dominated by Europeans at the time, Egypt was not yet a British protectorate, but instead nominally a part of the Ottoman Empire (and in reality a quasi-independent state. Before the Egyptian museum was built, the collection of antiquities was apparently kept in an annex of one of the palaces of the khedive of Egypt, who also inaugurated the Egyptian museum. So "colonial" is a bit misleading in this case...