First published: Sun 22 Oct 2023.
Els Slots
(T)Whs Of New York City
Comments
8 comments
Zoe
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 22, 2023)
New York City is the greatest city in the world! :)
Reply
Nan
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 22, 2023)
Re NYC skyline, I think the relevant skyscrapers are later than those in Chicago. There is a big batch of Art Deco skyscrapers (Flatiron, Chrysler, Empire State, ...) that probably deserve a place on the list.
Other sites I could see: The traditional neighborhoods in Brooklyn (redstones). The UN Building.
Jay T
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 22, 2023)
Glad you enjoyed your visit to New York City! I'm glad to hear an outside perspective on Ellis Island. Immigration is a big part of what makes the U.S. the U.S. (and I wish our politicians would remember that more), but I suppose it may not translate as well for those who don't have family that emigrated to the U.S. I also hadn't considered that the visit on Ellis Island is a lot more constricted than that of Liberty Island.
Jay T
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 22, 2023)
Central Park holds a special place for me because I appreciate how Olmsted kept nature within the city. I'll be curious to see how Birkenhead Park continues, and I should really get out there in the next year or two.
Also, glad you got to see the Guggenheim! Not my favorite FLW building, but it was interesting to see inside. I'm not sure I'll need to go back when the spiral ramp reopens.
Jay T
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 22, 2023)
As for the skyscrapers idea, I do think New York has some iconic buildings, and I'd be curious to see if they would ever be considered as having OUV.
What I like about the Chicago skyscrapers TWHS is that it is focused on the innovative design that changed the way the world approached constructing tall buildings.
Kyle Magnuson
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 22, 2023)
After visiting Angel Island in San Francisco a few years ago, I think I could only support Ellis Island for world heritage status if Angel Island was included.
Nan
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 23, 2023)
@Kyle: There is also the departure ports, e.g., Ballinstadt in Hamburg. Will post in the forum.
Ligocsicnarf89
1 year, 8 months ago (Oct 28, 2023)
NYC is truly a heritage treasure trove. I can see something such as 'Art Deco and Revivalist Skyscrapers of New York' making a great World Heritage Site. Other sites in NYC that could be awesome WHSs that come to mind are 'Grand Central Terminal', 'Carnegie Hall', the 'Moorish Revival Synagogues of New York', the 'New York Botanical Garden' and the 'SoHo-Cast Iron Historic District'. (: