Els Slots
Whs Plaques And Certificates
Over the years, many reviewers have pointed out the location of the WHS Plaque or a framed Certificate of Inscription in describing their visits. Finding them is almost a niche within a niche hobby! There is even a Flickr group dedicated to the subject (it got a bit sidetracked but the earlier entries do have some good examples) and a stock photo collection . Personally I am not so obsessed by this – I notice them in passing but usually am more interested in finding the OUV or an angle that has not been reviewed on this website yet. I even had a hard time finding photos of the things for this blog post.
But due to the general interest I’d like to poll how we can incorporate these markers in the website.
The Story behind the Plaques and Certificates
A few years ago already, Solivagant has explained the background story on these markers in depth in this forum topic. The bottom line is:
-
There are no “official” plaques that are handed out to new WHS, a site should place one (“whenever possible”) after having been inscribed.
-
“It should be so placed that it can easily be seen by visitors, without disfiguring the property”
-
“the World Heritage Emblem should appear on the plaque”
-
“the text should mention the property's Outstanding Universal Value”
-
The Certificate of Inscription (aka “Framed Paper Version”) has no official status in the Operational Guidelines, but seems to be sent out on the occasion of inscription or of official inauguration by a dignitary. Possibly also in multiple copies when there are serial locations.
What kind of markers have we spotted?
182 WHS reviews currently contain the word “plaque” (including 57 written by Clyde !), and 172 of them refer to the kind we mean here. Most of the time the appearance of the plaque is not further described, but we have at least:
- UNESCO plaque/manhole (Riga) ,
-
marble UNESCO WHS inscription plaque (Kromeriz, Arequipa, Paestum, Burgundy, Borobudur (black marble) ),
-
chrome UNESCO WHS plaque (Tugendhat),
-
a plaque attached to the rock surface (Alta, similar to Su Nuraxi (see 1st photo), Namhansanseong ),
- Samarkand also has a nice one resembling a book .
The Certificates of Inscription come in fewer appearances, most of the time it is the A4-sized paper in a simple frame. There is however a mixed form with the plaque: a bronze plaque with the inscription certificate engraved in it. Examples can be found in front of the Hoja Nasruddin statue in Bukhara and at Bahla Fort (see 3rd photo).
There are also many haphazard signs, as the one below from Abu Simbel, that do show the official logo but have no reference to the OUV of the WHS.
Where are they found?
The guideline “It should be so placed that it can easily be seen by visitors, without disfiguring the property” seems to be followed well. The certificate-style marker is usually found in museums / visitor centers / gift shops (even outside the core zone). In the Charles Darwin Research Station for Galapagos for example.
The metal plaques often are at the entrances of sites, near the ticket offices. Or on the floor in front of the actual monuments if they are in city centers.
The Rhaetian Railway has a red square one at every train station .
If we are going to dedicate a fixed corner of this website to WHS Plaques and Certificates, how should we organize this? Should we:
a. Create a connection where we log for each WHS: what kind of marker it is – where it is located. Adding a photo here would be hard, only a link would be possible.
b. Add a text in the info section to the right of each WH page, again with what kind of marker it is – where it is located. Small photos could be added. Against it could be argued that the info section is for more formal information and this stays trivial and is based on submissions of individuals.
c. Start our own Flickr group?
Or do you have another suggestion?
Comments
11 comments